| 59 | Colossus |
| 42 | Never Gonna Give You Up |
| 21 | Ironclad/Machinations (RE-ISSUE) |
| 21 | Unreleased & Forgotten |
| 18 | Rarest of Them All |
| 15 | Deadlift |
| 13 | Destroyer |
| 10 | Colossus Reborn (Deluxe Edition) |
| 10 | Bang Bang (Jessie J Cover) |
| 10 | Ironclad (RE-ISSUE) |
| 10 | Machinations (RE-ISSUE) |
| 9 | Live Judgement, Vol. 1 |
| 8 | A Very Arbiter Christmas [2019 Update] |
| 8 | Status Symbols |
| 8 | Live Judgement, Vol. 2 |
| 8 | A New Throne EP |
| 7 | Barter In Blood |
| 6 | Blackmail: The Worst of Arbiter ('07-'17) |
| 6 | Live Judgement, Vol. 0.5 |
| 3 | Farewell [Halloween Special] |